Brett,
Unless there has been a change by Edson our sheaves are made with just a bushing that rides on the pin. Original pins were bronze, new replacements are SS. You should be able to buy just one sheave, but I think they are made of an aluminum alloy now.
I recommend you call Edson and discuss your options with them. After you change out the sheave, if necessary, be sure you check all your sheaves and place some oil at the pin/sheave contact point.
Dave